I’ve sat on the post for years now. Trying to figure out what it is exactly I don’t like about this book, what bothered me so much about the concept behind this idea. And if I could sum up my thoughts into one sentence it would be this:
I think it’s a cheat book that doesn’t actually allow you to experience the full intimacy of real love.
Now that’s a pretty bold statement for a book with the tagline “The secret to love that lasts.” I didn’t come to this conclusion lightly. I wanted to like the book, especially as a relationship blogger, especially as a Christian. I kept reading and reading and couldn’t help but feel something was missing, something was just off.
You can’t work your way to love. Actions are the result of love, not the other way around. Sure, you can choose to do nice things for someone but we can’t assume the root is always love.
Actions are a choice. Love is not.
As I read the book, I started to notice a common theme of doing all things mentioned with whoever I was dating at the time. I was excited to. I looked for opportunities to do each one.
Words of affirmation.
Acts of service.
I did these because I love. I watch and observe. I notice little things. And I started to pick up on what he liked best. I think that’s what made it more special, honestly. Not that he had to tell me but that I cared to notice. You see, love and hurry don’t mix. Yet, this is what we’ve become accustomed to knowing, to doing.
When the Bible speaks of love, patient is the first attribute mentioned.
However, we live in a world of hurry. Efficiency. How can we get there quicker, faster, sooner.
We hurry with God.
We hurry with our spouse.
We hurry in our relationships.
The result is lost intimacy and counterfeit love.
I don’t want a cheat book. I want to figure it out on my own. I want to figure you out on my own. Isn’t that part of the fun?! I want someone to intentionally get to know me because they love me and want to know everything about me.
Not she told me she likes gifts so I will give her gifts. Or I will make time for him because that’s his love language. It’s not the gifts we are after, the time, the acts, the touch, the words… No, it’s the heart. A heart that’s full of love. That manifests itself through these common avenues. We chase these areas because they give us some glimmer of hope, perhaps a spark of love that satisfies us for a moment. But true love, real love is so much more, something so much deeper.
When real love hits, it’s not as complicated as we make it out to be. We won’t be chasing bandaid approaches that have a way of masking what is otherwise a loveless relationship, hanging by a thread. No, when you find love from the Creator of love, you won’t be able to help but love. Something changes. Your default changes. And all these tools and assessments will simply fall short when compared it.
2 thoughts on “Why I’ve never been a fan of “The Five Love Languages””
Yes! I’m not a fan of the 5 love languages either or the love and respect book ugh 😑
This was an interesting read. I appreciate your boldness to call out a book that has helped countless couples. However, I’d like to present a different point of view from yours. You say that love is not a choice. This is a naive point of view, yes love is a wonderful euphoric feeling but you have to choose daily to love someone. I absolutely love my husband but when I’m upset with him or disappointed I have a choice to respond unloving or lovingly. You may say those are actions but they are dictated by love. It’s kind of like in James where he says faith without works is dead and goes on to say I’ll show you my faith through my works. With love your actions show your love and without actions “I love you’s” only get so far.
I agree with you, learning how your spouse receives love is more fun through getting to know them, but honestly the book helped me identify the different ways people receive love and made me more aware of what my husband was receptive to and vice versa.